I have to disagree with Elanor Rigby. Yes it’s a quick tempo, but the E minor key makes it very bleak even without the lyrics. And I may be wrong but it’s also an overall pretty bleak song for Paul’s typical compositions. So it’s kind of always stood out to me.
I do love it very much though.
I would submit And Your Bird Can Sing as an upbeat melancholy song off Revolver.
I have to disagree with Elanor Rigby. Yes it’s a quick tempo, but the E minor key makes it very bleak even without the lyrics.
Those strings go hard, though.
I guess it depends on your definition of “upbeat.” It could mean cheerful and happy, or it could mean lively and fast-paced.
I don’t think being in a minor key is necessarily enough to invalidate the first definition, let alone the second. I’m not gonna link it because fuck R*edit, but there’s a thread there with plenty of examples of upbeat minor-key songs, including Uptown Funk, the Inspector Gadget theme, Get Lucky, Tunak Tunak Tun, Livin’ LA Vida Loca, Get the Party Started, etc.
I have to disagree with Elanor Rigby. Yes it’s a quick tempo, but the E minor key makes it very bleak even without the lyrics. And I may be wrong but it’s also an overall pretty bleak song for Paul’s typical compositions. So it’s kind of always stood out to me.
I do love it very much though.
I would submit And Your Bird Can Sing as an upbeat melancholy song off Revolver.
Those strings go hard, though.
I guess it depends on your definition of “upbeat.” It could mean cheerful and happy, or it could mean lively and fast-paced.
I don’t think being in a minor key is necessarily enough to invalidate the first definition, let alone the second. I’m not gonna link it because fuck R*edit, but there’s a thread there with plenty of examples of upbeat minor-key songs, including Uptown Funk, the Inspector Gadget theme, Get Lucky, Tunak Tunak Tun, Livin’ LA Vida Loca, Get the Party Started, etc.