You must log in or register to comment.
Client side TLS certs are basically the same stuff and it works nicely. Too bad they didn’t improve on that. My guess is that the big boys want to handle it at application layer.
To me they seem
A More user friendly
B Abstract away the burden of keeping the mTLS synchronized across devices
C Can be used in hardware and software.Feel free to correct me if my assumptions are wrong.
Is your B point properly addressed by Passkeys? With all this talk about export I presume not. Client certs seem abandoned, you can’t use it on mobile.
A passkey is a key pair where you keep the private key and give the public one to the service. Then you can log in by proving you have the private key. Fairly simple in theory. Horribly complex in practice.
Doesn’t a normal modern password, hashed, essentielly do the same thing?
No sane service has your actual password.
Yes, kind of. You’re still giving them your password every time you log in. And it’s on them whether they store it hashed or in plain text. With a passkey, you know that even if they’re hacked, they’ll never get your actual private key.
But, if they’re hacked, your key is probably the least of your concerns.
There’s a few differences. One is the length. Another is the randomness. The biggest, though, is that in a passkey, the server is verified as well. That means phishing is nearly impossible.
Yea, I’d rather have a 32 character password created by my password manager. Instead of adding individual keys to each device, having all decives access the same database is much simpler.
I think the only passkey I have is stored in my VaultWarden. Though it only works in browsers atm.
Works on android too.
Windows recently introduced support for Passkeys.
But it can only be used with Bitwarden, if you have Windows Hello enabled ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
And I don’t want to use anything else than a regular password.
What is the point of having a passkey on OneDrive ?
isn’t the whole point of OneDrive that you can access your files anywhere ?
Am I missing something here ?
Something I’m personally going to avoid as long as I can.
Not feeling great about the opening saying keys are necessarily locked to a single device. If that was true, they wouldn’t be in active use.
Yep. I use them because my password manager handles cross device passkeys. If I had to set passkeys up on every single device I use, per device per web service, I don’t think I’d bother with them…
Obligatory github drama https://github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/10407
It’s just bullshit that the ‘industry’ is trying to push because ‘security’, catch me dead before I give up access to my private keys to some faceless multibillion corpo
He does caveat that statement around 10 minutes into the video. But I still think it can be a useful technology even if it’s not portable since it can ease a typical sign in flow. I don’t think as this stage it’ll fully replace passwords.
Oh Dr. Mike, a little more gray at the temples. Why must time pass?
