So if my AI model is dumb as fuck and just reproduces whatever comes to its input, but technically still produces AI-generated content… does it make it an uncopywriting machine?
deleted by creator
I’ve seen that discussed as a genuinely serious problem for open source code. LLMs can be used to try to strip off a license.
That’s not how it works - the original author of the input owns the copyright for the work and if the output of the LLM is the same or a close derivative, the that copyright will be infringed. The ruling only means that YOU can not claim copyright for something that LLM spit out and you put your name on.
The key word in all this is “transformative.”
If you turn a thousand books into one book that’s not quite like any of the others… congratulations, that’s how writing works. Most authors read.
If you turn one book into the same book, that’s plainly not the same thing.

