• 0 Posts
  • 66 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2024

help-circle

  • Put aside all your personal feelings about money - how much you make, have, save, spend, or need. Money doesn’t mean anything, it is just a means of exchanging value so that someone who does plumbing for a living doesn’t have to also grow their own food and mine the metal to make the pipes.

    A market economy is decentralized, there is no single decision-maker that mandates how many plumbers need to exist or how much pipe needs to be manufactured. Those decisions are made by market forces I.e. profit.

    The information about how valuable something, someone, or some skill is in a decentralized system is determined through transaction. Money needs to flow in order to get accurate prices for everything and determine their value - valuable things have a market price that exceeds their costs to produce/maintain/etc. The greater the liquidity in a market (and the lower the cost to transact), the more accurate this information.

    Inflation incentivizes spending money - on goods, services, or assets, rather than holding the currency itself. It can be thought of as a tax for withholding participation in the market. It increases liquidity and facilitates price discovery.

    Broad deflation - the price of everything falling - is generally a sign of economic collapse. It means that no one wants what the economy is producing at the prices it can sustain… so stop making everything… food, houses, etc.

    Sector deflation is quite common - electronics (until recently) got cheaper for decades - and this generally reflects increasing production efficiency and healthy marketplace competiton (good). But people spending less on TVs need to find somewhere else to spend that money to keep the system operating. Reducing spend overall is the signal to reduce output, which means recession, unemployment, etc. Economic contraction makes everyone poorer.

    None of this would be bad if the life of the median person wasn’t balanced on a knife’s edge over the abyss of homelessness and poverty. Against that backdrop, it can often seem cruel that the system is designed in such a way that everything gets more expensive all the time. If your earnings aren’t keeping up with or exceeding inflation, however, it is the system telling you that the role is being culled. Find a new job (obviously easier said than done in most cases).



  • I’d personally rather see her jump to the Senate for a term, or NY Governor, before trying for the presidency. I’d say the same for any House rep. Governors and Senators have the clearest parallels to the office, as executive and foreign-policy roles themselves.

    I think AOC is a high-variance candidate - much the same way Trump was in 2016 - and she will either get much more or much less support than expected in the general election.

    I think her biggest electoral baggage will be her statements over the years on the ‘Woke 1.0’ items that the electorate soured on. She has moderated her past statements here more recently, which leaves a lot of doubt as to her actual beliefs and policy goals. She’ll be attacked for that from the left and the right, and it will take oxygen away from a progressive economic agenda that would likely be broadly popular if explained well.

    Whoever the dem candidate ends up being, I doubt they can rely on the same level of support as the party received in the midterms. 2 years is an eternity in politics and 2028 will likely be defined by some new crisis that isn’t even on our radar right now. If she runs, I’ll likely vote for her (at least, based on who else seems to be running as of now).


  • There needs to be some distinction and nuance to this conversation.

    Adult sports is and entirely different kettle of fish from youth sports. Studies have shown that after ~2 years on HRT, trans women have performance in line with cis women, rather than cis men. For adult leagues, this is about as clear of an evidence-driven requirement as there can be, and it helpfully eliminates the ‘I’m going to identify as a women for the WNBA draft so I can make a political statement’ stuff. Adult sports careers, even in the most demanding sports are at least ~10yrs long, giving enough time to meet the HRT requirement.

    For youth sports, particularly highschool just post-puberty, there is not a clear distinction. If we stick the same 2-year HRT cutoff, that would effectively eliminate trans participation in sports already, as full medical transitioning is rare at that young of an age, and anyone who decided to transition after the start of the sophomore year season would be ineligible for their remaining time in high school. This would mean the child would need to commit to full medical transition by the age of 15-16 at the latest - in which case they could play one season in their senior year. I don’t think this kind of time pressure would be healthy for young people making that kind of choice.

    If we can’t use that evidence-driven criterion, we are just out in the messy jungle of feelings and politics.

    Frankly, I don’t see a solution that satisfies every consideration for this case. All kids should get to play sports, but it should also be as fair as possible to every participant. Kids shouldn’t feel hopeless because someone on their team or the other team is literally built differently, nor should a trans athlete be denied real competition and opportunities to learn through failure and effort.

    There are basically 4 options:

    1. Athletes are required to play in their birth gender until 2 years of HRT
    2. Athletes can freely choose which league to play in
    3. Exclude transgender people from sports
    4. Case-by-case basis rife with potential for abuse, confusion, and resentment

    Each of them will make some people very unhappy, and ultimately be unfair to some subset of the trans population.




  • skibidi@lemmy.worldtomemes@lemmy.world•RAM and Ditch
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    17 days ago

    In the most charitable light, his statement had merit. Same way as there is a resource allocation issue with cars - the vast majority of them sit around for the vast majority of the time.

    If tech companies hadn’t spent the last 30 years aggressively fucking everyone over for every penny they could get, maybe we would be more inclined to take the charitable view rather than see his statements as yet another attempt to add a fence and charge a toll.






  • skibidi@lemmy.worldtoComic Strips@lemmy.world•Regional identity
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    26 days ago

    You can stick a fancy facade on basically any wall construction to make it look like an old-half timbered style, or brick, or stone, etc.

    But trying to actually build an old brick/stone/plaster and timber monstrosity today wouldn’t be smart. Insulation, moisture control, energy efficiency, and even creature comforts like wifi signal penetration are all miles better with newer construction methods.

    I agree the architecture is boring, but again, it doesn’t have to look this way. However, I think most people would rather have the soulless gray box than have uncontrollable mold spreading across their walls unless they leave the windows open in winter.


  • And yes, you can train out biases. Rather easily, actually. You don’t even have to adjust weights. You post-train through rules files.

    The assertion is not about whether ‘you’ can do it. It is that the model cannot do this itself.

    A human recognizing a bias in the model and correcting it is not evidence robot intelligence, it is further evidence for human intelligence.

    Training is absolute, it determines the set of relationships the model can represent between input and output. Context, rules files, system prompts, etc. operate only on the conditional probabilities within this set and are impermanent. This is ‘priming’ in human psychology, and why a person in a herpetology class will talk about Pythonic features differently than in a coding class.

    As an example of how this is not real learning and is inadequate to solve real problems, here is a paper where the authors challenged multiple models to solve unfamiliar games where they need to discover the rules through play and feedback. Even the ‘best’ model performed pitifully compared to humans.


  • There’s some semantics here.

    Large neural networks have been shown to build parallel models of the world that they learn through their training data. A chess model trained only on chess move notation does have an interior board and state that it tracks, despite never being told about a board, the number of pieces, how they move, etc.

    LLMs do something similar with language, mapping tokens to ideas in ways that can produce meaningful and grammatically correct output without needing to be formally taught any of this.

    Our brains also do things like this - we observe X and then try to intuit Y, the truth of the world and reason for X.

    Where this breaks down is humans can then take our guess for Y and propose Z, and try to find it out in the world. If we can’t, then Y is probably wrong, and our new understanding of the world is Y* that is consistent both with X and the absence of Z.

    I cannot stress enough how far we are from machines that can do this. They can learn to approximate Y through training, but they have no means to extend that to propose an unobserved Z, no means to update their internal state given the results of that observation (without fully retraining the model on new data - which makes it a new model), and no way to question X given Z - they can talk at great length about data biases but can literally never excise bad data from their training weights. There have been experiments with training models on time-boxed datasets (e.g. stuff up to AD 1880) and asking it about modern concepts - predictably hilarious results.

    All the current ‘AI’ stuff is smoke and mirrors around this very hard problem. The machines can talk, but they can’t think (Z) and can’t learn (Y*).




  • Doing something yourself always teaches you better than watching it, or just being told the answer.

    A neat result from pedagogical studies is that being given the worked solutions to new problems to study from is much more effective for learning the material than simply practicing.

    Students who were assigned practice problems performed worse on later tests than those given the same problems and all of the worked-out solutions for them. The explanation from the research was - when learning a new topic, immediate practice isn’t beneficial because the student doesn’t yet know what to practice. If they are lost when trying the problem, they can easily end up practicing the wrong skills by not knowing where to start. Those with the solutions have some of the cognitive burden removed, and are better able to internalize the task and generalize it to later problems.

    I completely agree with you on LLMs and I think they’ll be a disaster for education. But I’ve always found it interesting that being given the answer can be useful for learning in certain circumstances.



  • How the robot proves these statement is by writing LEAN code that represents the math. If the lean compiles, the math was valid. If it doesn’t, it tries again.

    It will do this forever until it finds a solution.

    Goedel predicted this in 1933, btw. From his work on formal systems, he ascertained that since every mathematical statement is trivially true following from the rigorous application of the axioms of mathematics or entirely false, theorems could be checked and proven automatically.

    These systems are able to prove statements at a scale beyond humans, because they have effectively infinite time to exhaustively explore applying every rule.

    Unfortunately, this isn’t all that helpful for the various fields of math as a whole. Effectively they have a list of statements and a second column with ‘true’ or ‘false’, but the actual route taken by the models to get that answer is often incredibly indirect and therefore difficult to gain insight from and apply to new areas. The approach taken to produce an answer is often more valuable to the field than the answer itself.

    The field moves forward when the people in it understand the new results and techniques sufficiently to begin asking new questions, simply giving the answer isn’t all that useful. The robots cannot (yet) do this. Someone has to, at a minimum, pose the question in formal mathematical language. There are an infinite number of true statements in mathematics ( trivial example 1=1, 2=2, …) asking the interesting questions is the important part. The field will still only advance as fast as the people in it are able to digest results.

    Further, results in pure math do not generalize to the more applied fields that directly affect our ability to do things. Most engineering formulae are NOT rigorously true - they are weak approximations with envelopes of applicability. The same is true even in base physics. So while a robot can crank through ten million lines of lean to prove an obscure theorem, it cannot think about physics for a week and come up with a theory of quantum gravity.