Your team’s code review process is probably an expensive illusion of quality. Here’s what the evidence says, and what to do instead.

TL;DR

  • Pull requests were designed for open source contributions from untrusted strangers. Applying them to trusted teams is a category error.
  • Peer-reviewed research shows code review’s primary value is knowledge transfer, not bug detection. Less than 15% of review comments relate to actual bugs.
  • Async PR workflows mean your code spends 86-99% of its lead time waiting. One organisation spent 130,000 hours in a single year waiting on PRs that received zero comments.
  • DORA research across 36,000+ professionals shows trunk-based development correlates with dramatically higher software delivery performance, and faster code reviews alone improve performance by 50%.
  • The alternative is T*D: Test-Driven Development (build quality in), Trunk-Based Development (integrate continuously), and Team-focused Development (review during creation, not after).
  • The transition is gradual: optimise PRs first, adopt Ship/Show/Ask, then move to pairing and trunk-based development as trust and automation mature.-
    • TehPers@beehaw.orgEnglish
      8·
      14 days ago

      This. I can’t get them to run lints or tests on their own, and I can’t get the person in charge of the repo to let us run the CI automatically on PR. Combine that with the rampant slop, and a good number of the PRs are just plain unreviewable.

      Then you run into the other issue: the PRs get merged too fast to review them properly. How someone approves 50 changed files in a PR with +30000 and -150 lines changed in under an hour is beyond me, to be honest.

      • FizzyOrange@programming.dev
        5·
        13 days ago

        I can’t get the person in charge of the repo to let us run the CI automatically on PR

        Ouch. Time for a new job. (I’m not even joking - I’d quit if it was that bad.)

        • TehPers@beehaw.orgEnglish
          5·
          13 days ago

          In this case, it’s a customer’s environment, so it’s actually not one of my direct coworkers that’s blocking this. Otherwise I’d agree.